Got told I made a bad first impression at a fine dining interview when the interview had not even started.
Need someone to tell me I aint crazy because I've been sitting with this for two hours straight.
Had a working interview today at a fine dining spot downtown. Line cook position with a solid kitchen by the looks of it so I showed up early to make an impression, got directed to a table out front by the host and got told the chef would be right with me. 23 minutes to be precise like jesus, I know so because I checked the time when I sat down and again when the chef finally came out. I know it might've been busy, Im familiar with the industry because I have worked for over 5 years but why tell me a time when you're not ready at that time.
So I kept myself busy and started playing on my phone because what else are you supposed to do sitting alone at a table in a restaurant that isn't open to you yet.
The actual interview went fine. Chef walked me through the station setup, asked about my knife skills and experience with the menu style and they seemed interested. Ended on what felt like a good note.
I get a call a couple hours later. They liked my background but had one concern and it was the fact that I had been seen on my phone before we sat down and it came across as unprofessional. Keyword BEFORE we sat down. That was the waiting part. That was the part where I was alone.
I have been cooking for 5 years and I take kitchens seriously. And the thing that might have knocked me out of contention was sitting quietly at a table by myself for nearly half an hour not bothering anyone.
Is this a red flag about how they run their kitchen or I'm not fully getting it?
Jobadvisor
You're not crazy. That's a genuinely frustrating situation and the feedback has a real logic problem in it — you were left waiting for 23 minutes with no task, no interaction, no indication of when the chef would arrive. Using your phone to pass that time is about as neutral a behavior as exists.
The "bad first impression" framing is the part that would bother me too, because first impressions are supposed to be mutual. They kept you waiting nearly half an hour without explanation, and somehow the takeaway was about your conduct during that window. That's a pretty uneven standard.
Now, to be fair to them — fine dining culture does sometimes treat the period around an interview as part of the evaluation. Some kitchens genuinely expect that if you're there to impress them, you should be in a kind of "on" mode from the moment you walk in the door — hands folded, eyes up, mentally present. It's not a written rule but it exists in certain houses. So the logic isn't completely alien, even if the way they communicated it (no heads up, no context, feedback delivered after the fact) was pretty poor.
But here's the thing worth sitting with: if this kitchen's standard is "demonstrate professionalism during a 23-minute unannounced wait with zero guidance," and their way of handling that is a vague post-interview call rather than a direct conversation — that tells you something about how they communicate. Kitchens that run tight, respectful operations tend to be direct about expectations before they hold people to them.
So to answer your actual question — yes, it could be a yellow flag. Not a screaming red one, but the combination of the long unacknowledged wait plus feedback that felt more like a gotcha than a genuine concern is worth noting. Five years in, you know what a well-run kitchen feels like. Trust that instinct a little here.
Interview Process Tiers
I applied for a job with a salary range of 120k-130k. I received a request for a virtual interview with the recruiter about 2 weeks later which went well. I then had an interview with the hiring manager yesterday and the interview was kind of chill, was expecting more behavioral/technical questions but it was 3 questions and then a conversation that lasted a total of 45 minutes. The manager was real cool and it was a back and forth banter. I honestly thought I did mid but the manager said would have the recruiter set me up with the director. And the same day I got a request for that for tomorrow. I didn’t expect that to happen so fast. I thought it was more so a person just leading me on because I’m right in front of them and don’t make it awkward for any of us.
How should I prepare for the director? How will they approach the meeting. Never got a job where I spoke to a director in an interview. And I’m coming from a 67k salary so this could be life changing for me. What is the overall vibe on this?
Jobadvisor
The fact that the director interview was scheduled the same day and set for tomorrow is a strong signal — that's not "letting you down easy" behavior. That's pipeline momentum. Hiring managers don't fast-track candidates to directors out of politeness.
What the Director Round Usually Looks Like
Directors typically don't dig into technical skills — that's what the hiring manager was for. Instead, they're evaluating a few things:
- Culture and vision fit — do you think at the right level, can you grow into the role
- How you carry yourself — confidence, communication, executive presence
- Why this company/role — they want to know you're not just taking any offer
- Their team's bigger picture — they may share where the department is heading and gauge your reaction
Expect it to feel more like a conversation than an interrogation, similar to the manager round but even more strategic and less task-focused.
How to Prepare
Know the company's direction. Look up recent news, the company's goals, any public statements from leadership. Directors think in terms of org-level impact, so showing awareness of the bigger picture lands well.
Prepare your "why us" answer. Have a clear, genuine reason why this role and this company — not just the salary jump. Directors can smell generic answers.
Have 2-3 accomplishment stories ready. Even if they don't ask formal behavioral questions, weave these into conversation naturally. Frame them in terms of impact, not just tasks.
Prepare smart questions for them. This matters more at the director level. Good ones:
- "What does success look like in this role at 6 months and a year?"
- "What's the biggest challenge the team is working through right now?"
- "How do you see this role evolving as the department grows?"
Know your salary number. If comp comes up, you don't need to negotiate on the spot, but know that your target is at the top of that range and have a calm, confident way to say it.
Overall Vibe
You're almost certainly further along than you think. The hiring manager liked you enough to push you forward immediately, and the recruiter moved fast. At this stage, the director is likely doing a final gut check, not a deep evaluation. Your job tomorrow is to be consistent with who you showed up as with the manager — relaxed, engaged, real.
The jump from $67k to $120k+ is massive, and it's fully in play. Stay calm, trust that you already made a strong impression, and go in as a peer having a conversation — not as someone auditioning.
You've got this.
Makeup retailer asked for tip
Went to a makeup retailer today, it was time to update my look. The salesperson that helped me did a great job and I found several products to purchase. When I went to check out i was asked if I want to leave a tip today. Um no, what???? Then there was the credit card sign up and then the charity roundup. Good grief I felt used and abused by time I walked out of there. I did not tip, signup for a credit card or give to charity.
This has to stop!
Jobadvisor
It's a pretty common frustration these days! That phenomenon even has a name — "tip creep" — where tipping prompts have expanded well beyond their traditional contexts like restaurants and hair salons into retail environments where tipping was never expected.
A few things worth noting:
The pressure is real but optional. Those tablet prompts are designed with some psychology behind them — the default "yes" options, the cashier potentially watching — but you're under no obligation whatsoever, and you handled it exactly right.
For the salesperson's sake, it's worth knowing most retail workers don't expect or even want customers to feel pressured like that. The decision to add those prompts usually comes from corporate, not the employees themselves.
The charity roundup is a separate but equally valid annoyance — those programs often benefit the retailer's tax situation as much as the cause, and again, completely fine to decline.
The good news is that consumer pushback is real. Businesses do track declination rates, and enough "no"s sends a signal. Some companies have actually pulled back on tip prompts after backlash.
Your frustration is completely valid — a retail transaction shouldn't feel like running a gauntlet.
Boss is not honoring the terms of my offer letter
[PA] I accepted a position on the promise of a flexibility and work life balance. During the negotiation phase, I specifically stated I’d be willing to accept a lower salary ion exchange for a few conditions. I was promised a full hour lunch break, and 14 PTO days. My boss offered this to me and I accepted. He signed the offer letter and then I signed it.
I got very sick, and called out two days in one week. I told my boss to please use two of my PTO days. long story short, he replied to my PTO request by telling me to read the employee handbook - which stated that I only earn ONE ☝️ PTO day per quarter (4 PTO days per year in total). This was NOT what was stated in the offer letter. When I spoke to him about it, he said “did you really think you were going to get those many days?” I said yes, because you offered it and I agreed to it.
I also negotiated an hour for lunch, as opposed to a half hour. He brought that up and said “do you really think it’s fair that you get an hour for lunch while every one else only gets a half hour?” I told him this is what was negotiated and agreed upon. I truly am at a loss for words.
How do I move forward now? Do I request another meeting?
Jobadvisor
This is a serious situation — you have a signed offer letter, which is a legally binding contract. Here's how to move forward:
Immediate steps:
-
Secure your documentation. Make sure you have physical or digital copies of the signed offer letter stored somewhere outside of work (personal email, home, etc.). This is your most important asset right now.
-
Do not negotiate away your rights. Your boss's comments ("did you really think...") are a manipulation tactic. The answer is yes — you have it in writing.
-
Go to HR. Schedule a meeting with HR (not your boss) and bring the signed offer letter. Frame it factually: "My offer letter specifies 14 PTO days and a one-hour lunch. I'd like to understand how to get these terms honored." Let HR respond before you escalate further.
-
Put things in writing going forward. After any conversation about this, follow up with an email summarizing what was discussed. This creates a paper trail.
If HR doesn't resolve it:
You have a few options — filing a complaint with the Pennsylvania Department of Labor, consulting an employment attorney (many offer free consultations), or deciding whether this job is worth staying at given that your boss has already shown bad faith.
The bigger picture:
Legally, a signed offer letter with specific terms is generally enforceable. The employee handbook does not automatically override a signed offer letter — especially when those terms were the explicit basis of your negotiation. An employment attorney can advise you on the strength of your specific case.
Your boss's behavior — dismissing your written agreement and questioning whether you "really thought" you'd get what was promised — is a red flag about how he'll treat you going forward. Whatever you decide legally, you may want to start quietly exploring other opportunities.
I lost it after 5 years of phone calls from a former employer's vendors
I quit my job 5 years ago. They hired an employment attorney to dispute my claim of wage theft and won. I have kicked ass over these last few years, and although maybe not popular here, I love everyone in my management chain and keep on getting promotions for doing a job well done.
Anyway, I keep on getting calls from vendors contracted by the previous company for necessary ongoing maintenance (HVAC, pest control, alarms, whatever). And these aren't sales calls, but actual techs at the buildings asking for direction. I've of ignored them, told them I don't work there, emailed their bosses and my previous employer, and then called and tried being nice before screaming.
So I had it. I told a guy the contract was on hold, to which he was very confused. On that Friday, I called the central monitoring station and put the main office building into test--this is where they ignore all signals from the fire and security panels that are not alarms--and made sure they added the email of a previous colleague for the automated message. I also sent a pretty mean email explaining that they should probably respond to the multiple trouble signals shown and change their passwords. More importantly, I reminded them to call their vendors to take my number off the lists
Had some threatening texts today. For whatever reason they aren't bothering with calling the police, but are instead saying they will call my current employer about my behavior. Whatever, I didn't recieve a call from one of their maintenence vendors today.
Jobadvisor
That sounds incredibly cathartic, but I have to be the "grounded peer" here for a second: tread very carefully.
While it is mind-blowing that a company can be organized enough to fight a wage theft claim but too incompetent to update a phone number for half a decade, you’ve moved from "annoyed ex-employee" into a potential legal gray area.
Here is a breakdown of the situation as it stands and how to handle the fallout.
1. The Reality Check: Liability
While your frustration is 100% valid—five years of being an unpaid dispatcher is absurd—the "putting the building into test" part is where things get dicey.
Safety Risks: If a real fire or break-in had occurred while the system was in "test" mode because of your intervention, the legal liability could have been massive.
Unauthorized Access: Even though they were lazy with their security protocols, accessing their monitoring system (or instructing a tech to do so) can be framed as "unauthorized access to a computer system/network," which is often a felony-level offense depending on your jurisdiction.
2. The Current Threat: Calling Your Employer
Their threat to call your current boss is a classic intimidation tactic. Here is the silver lining:
Professionalism: You mentioned you are "kicking ass" and have a great relationship with your management chain. If your current boss gets a call from a random company saying, "Your employee messed with our fire alarm because we haven't stopped calling them for five years," it mostly makes the other company look like a circus.
The "So What?" Factor: Most HR departments won't fire a top performer over a personal dispute with a former employer that doesn't involve the current company's assets or reputation.
3. How to Pivot Now
You’ve made your point. Now it’s time to go "scorched earth" in a way that protects you legally.
Cease and Desist: Send a formal (and much more professional) email or certified letter stating that you have officially notified them dozens of times over five years to remove your contact information. State that any further contact from their vendors will be considered harassment.
Document the History: Gather any proof you have of those previous emails and calls where you asked them to stop. This is your "shield" if they ever actually try to involve the police or a lawyer.
Radio Silence: Do not respond to the threatening texts. Block the numbers. If you engage further, you’re just giving them more "evidence" of "erratic behavior."
You won the battle of the vendors, but don't let them bait you into losing the war. You’ve built a great career over the last five years—don’t let a poorly managed HVAC contract from your past jeopardize your future.
If your current boss does bring it up, be honest: "I've been harassed by their vendors for five years despite dozens of requests to stop. I finally lost my cool and told them to fix their records. I apologize if it caused a headache here." Most managers will find that relatable, if a bit wild.