The Great Debate. Check Work Email On Weekends Or Not?



A colleague recently reached out on social media to ask if I’d seen an email he sent. When I replied that I typically don't check work emails on the weekend, I was blindsided by the reaction. The comments weren't critical; they were filled with surprise and even admiration.

It was a wake-up call. My personal boundary—one I’ve maintained for years—is apparently an anomaly in my professional circle. It begs the question: In our hyper-connected world, has the "always-on" culture become our new, unhealthy baseline?

The Myth of the "Easy" Academic Life

As a professor, atmospheric scientist, and Associate Dean at a major university, my "typical" day is a whirlwind. The common narrative suggests academia is just an extended high school with some teaching on the side. In reality, we are juggling research, grant proposals, student advising, administrative fires, and international conferences.

When you add a leadership role to that faculty workload, the pressure doesn't just add up—it multiplies. In this environment, the glorification of overwork isn't just common; it’s practically a job requirement.

Is Overwork a Badge of Honor or a Health Hazard?

Scholars like Jenna Mittelmeier have noted that academia valorizes being "perpetually overburdened." We’ve created a culture of cultural inertia, where people feel they must check emails on Saturday just to keep their heads above water on Monday.

But this "crisis culture" comes with a steep price tag:

  • Mental & Physical Health: Constant stress without detachment leads to burnout.

  • Equity Issues: Always-on expectations disproportionately hurt primary childcare providers.

  • Relationship Strain: You can't be "present" at a family dinner if your mind is in your inbox.

Working Smarter, Not Harder

Before you label me a slacker, let’s look at the data. I am consistently one of the most productive researchers in my college. I’ve been elected to three prestigious national academies and host a podcast for the Weather Channel.

My secret isn't working more hours; it's optimizing the ones I have.

  1. Identify Your Biorhythms: I write early in the morning when my brain is sharpest.

  2. Strategic Availability: I aim to be available appropriately, not constantly.

  3. Perspective: Most "fires" that pop up on a Saturday morning can wait until Monday.

The Science of "Email Anticipation"

Interestingly, research from the Academy of Management suggests that checking email after hours actually impedes productivity. It isn't just the time spent replying; it’s the "mere norm of availability." The constant anticipation of a work request creates a stressor that prevents true detachment. If you never fully "unplug," you never fully recharge.

Your Work is Not Your Identity

I value my research and my students immensely. But at the end of the day, my identity isn't found in a published paper or a cleared inbox. It’s found in watching my kids play sports, enjoying a quiet evening on the patio with my wife, or heading to a basketball championship.

The world will keep turning if you don’t reply to that 9:00 PM Friday email until Monday morning. I promise.


Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post