.jpg)
There's a particular kind of workplace dynamic that's hard to name but instantly recognizable: the colleague who responds to your feedback with "Excellent spot!" — as if you've just cracked a code rather than done your job.
A reader wrote in describing exactly this with a newer direct report. He's warm, encouraging, and great with his team. The problem? He's equally warm and encouraging with everyone above him, including her. Every correction she makes earns a glowing "That's a really good point." Every suggestion gets a cheerful "Great idea, [name]!" Every instruction is met with what sounds less like acknowledgment and more like a performance review she didn't ask for.
As she put it: "I actually phrased it as an instruction."
The thing is, none of it is egregious. He's not being argumentative or undermining her authority. He takes her feedback and acts on it. But the relentlessness of it — the constant stream of approval from someone who reports to her — has started to feel patronizing, like being praised by a very enthusiastic substitute teacher.
So what's actually going on here?
One possibility: he's deflecting. "Excellent spot!" is a way of acknowledging a mistake without really sitting with it. The focus shifts from I got that wrong to you caught it brilliantly. If the pattern is that he compliments his way past accountability, that's worth watching.
But there's another, more charitable read: he might simply be in the same mode with everyone. He's supportive and encouraging with his team — that's literally how he described to be — and maybe he just hasn't calibrated that those habits land differently when directed upward. He's not being condescending so much as he's treating his manager like a peer he really, really likes.
Does it change the feeling if you see it that way?
My take: if he's accepting direction, fixing mistakes, and not reserving this behavior for women or people he's trying to manage upward strategically, this probably lives in the category of annoying quirk rather than actionable problem. Everyone has a thing. This is his thing.
That said, if she wants to say something, she absolutely can — and she doesn't need a grand speech to do it. A dry, in-the-moment response can work surprisingly well. Something like a raised eyebrow and "An 'okay, got it' works fine" — said lightly, not as a reprimand — is often enough to recalibrate someone without making it A Whole Conversation.
The goal isn't to make him less enthusiastic. It's just to redirect some of that enthusiasm back where it belongs: toward his actual work, not toward narrating how excellent his manager is at hers.