Is joining the military a good option as a last resort?

 


Is it a bad idea to go to back to school at 44 part time?

I don't think I could handle a ft job and ft school at the same time. I was thinking of going to school for some type of engineering . Maybe civil or mechanical. It would probably take me 6 years to finish part time. I think anyway. And I would have to borrow money since I'm poor.


Jobadvisor


Going back to school part-time at 44 is not inherently a bad idea, but for an engineering degree funded entirely by debt, it carries substantial financial and structural risks that require careful calculation.

The Reality of an Engineering Degree Part-Time

FactorWhat to ExpectKey Risk / Consideration
Timeline6 to 8 yearsEngineering degrees typically require 120–130 credits with rigid, sequential prerequisites (Math $\rightarrow$ Physics $\rightarrow$ Core Engineering). Taking 6–8 credits per semester puts you at 6–8 years.
Class SchedulesDaytime daytime labsUnlike business or IT programs, upper-level civil and mechanical engineering courses rarely offer evening or asynchronous online options. Lab sections almost always run during typical work hours.
Financial ROIHigh upside, high debt riskStarting entry-level engineering salaries range from $\$70,000$ to $\$85,000$. However, taking out student loans at 44 means borrowing for living expenses and tuition, leaving you with fewer working years post-graduation to pay it off before retirement.

Key Financial & Logistics Scrutiny

  • Return on Investment (ROI) vs. Age: Graduating around age 50–52 leaves you with 15–17 years in the field before typical retirement. Borrowing tens of thousands of dollars late in your career can severely compress your ability to save for retirement, as high monthly loan payments will eat into your new engineering salary.

  • Workplace Flexibility: Because upper-division courses (like Thermodynamics, Fluid Mechanics, or Structural Analysis) require mandatory, mid-day lab blocks, maintaining a standard 40-hour 9-to-5 job is extremely difficult without an extraordinarily flexible employer.

  • Math Foundation: Civil and Mechanical engineering require heavy calculus (Calculus I–III), Differential Equations, and Calculus-based Physics. If you haven't taken higher-level math recently, you may need 1–2 semesters of remedial math before even starting degree-level coursework, extending your timeline.

4 Strategic Steps to Test the Waters Safely

  1. Start at a Community College (Cash Pay / Pell Grant): Complete all general education, general chemistry, physics, and calculus at a local community college. Community college tuition is dramatically lower, often covered by federal Pell Grants if you qualify based on income, preventing early debt accumulation.

  2. Verify ABET Accreditation & Transfer Pathways: Ensure the 4-year university you plan to transfer to is ABET-accredited (essential for engineering licensure) and has a formal articulation agreement with your community college so every credit transfers seamlessly.

  3. Audit Upper-Level Class Schedules Early: Look at the current course catalogs and class schedules for 3rd- and 4th-year civil/mechanical classes at your target university. Confirm whether those classes are offered outside standard work hours.

  4. Explore Engineering Technology (BSET) Alternatives: If rigid math requirements or daytime labs pose a barrier, consider a Bachelor of Science in Engineering Technology (BSET). BSET programs are often more applied, frequently offer evening or hybrid schedules for working adults, and lead to strong career paths in field engineering, project management, and drafting.

Is joining the military a good option as a last resort?

To keep things short, I'm 24m and I've basically wasted the past 6 years since high school. I've had a couple jobs that didn't last long and I've been working part time in a grocery store for the past 4 years. I feel like I've gotten complacent even though I know I want more out of a career. I know I need to be proactive or I'll never get out of this hole I've put myself in. I don't really have any solid ideas of what to pursue but I know I need to take action regardless.

So I was thinking that I'd give myself until the end of November to knuckle down and do research to really find some things that I'd want to try. but if I can't manage that for whatever reason than I want something that I can force myself to do that could help get momentum going. I'm Canadian and our military has some options for learning trades or paying for schooling. It would also force me to break routine and physically change locations which I think I really need right now.

Really not sure if that's the best choice I could make, but at this point, I'm in the worst case scenario by simply not choosing anything. Is there anything else that could be a decent last resort? Probably something I wouldn't have to think about much and would help me build the momentum that I need.


Jobadvisor

Joining can be a good option, but the timing doesn't fit a November backstop. The Auditor General's review of CAF recruitment from 2022 to 2025 found that the median time for an applicant to be recruited was between 245 and 271 days, and most applicants voluntarily left the process. Even if you applied this week, a start in spring or summer 2027 is realistic. That's useful, though. Applying now is the action you're looking for. It puts real steps on a calendar (screening, medical, interview) and doesn't lock you in until you accept an offer. You can keep researching while the process runs.

The Reserve and Regular Force are very different choices. The Reserve is part-time, and Reserve members may serve while going to school or working at a civilian job. They are paid during their training and are not posted or required to do a military move. That's a lower-risk way to build momentum without giving up your current life. The Regular Force is the bigger reset, and it's the one that matches what you said you need: relocation and a real change of routine. It also comes with more commitment. Funded schooling in an older CAF page came with a service obligation after graduation, so check current terms before you sign anything. Wanting out of where you are is a legitimate reason to join, but you'd be doing the job every day, so it's worth asking whether you'd be okay with the work itself.

If the military doesn't feel right, a few other options have built-in deadlines and can change your routine quickly. Many colleges run January intakes for certificate programs, and their application deadlines often come earlier than people expect, so check those this week. If a trade interests you, look for a pre-apprenticeship course or an employer willing to hire you as a helper and register you as an apprentice, so you're paid while you learn. A short seasonal or contract job in a different city would also break your routine right away, with far less commitment than the CAF.

For the November deadline, I'd change the goal from "research or join" to something you control. By November 30, have at least one real application submitted and your next step booked. Research can continue alongside that.

On the six years, I'd push back a little. Four years of steady work at 24 isn't nothing, and you still have a lot of runway. The bigger risk is letting the deadline pass with nothing moving. If the flatness feels heavier than being stuck, like low energy or nothing seeming worth doing, it's worth raising with a doctor, since that can make every option harder to start.

What have you been even vaguely curious about? Even a rough answer would help me narrow down your research.


Boss wants me to work for free, how do I handle this?

so they're not "mandating" or forcing it but strongly recommending it

basically i get paid hourly and we have agreed upon hours in the week with the caveat in the contract that it depends on business needs. this hasn't affected me yet but things started to shift the last few months

the boss is turning non customer events into "closed hours" and not mandating us to work per se but strongly "encouraging" it and 75% of people are agreeing to it making everyone look bad. i have multiple examples but the most ridiculous one is this

- during a normal 8 hour shift, midway through the day we are "closing the doors" to customers for 60 minutes to have someone come in and interview us for a local ad. we are told we will be UNPAID any time the doors are closed to customers but other team events are happening. so this "Event" it's like 2-3pm when my shift ends at 5pm, I "don't have to be there" but "why wouldn't I want to help with marketing the business which helps bring in customers and pays my salary" was the logic. everyone else on shift that day has decided to go along with this. I guess my option is to walk out and come back at 3pm. he knows he can't fire me for this but i feel like this puts a target on my back unfairly


Jobadvisor

What your boss is asking is not just unfair; depending on your jurisdiction, it is almost certainly illegal.

If you are an hourly non-exempt employee, wage and hour laws (such as the Fair Labor Standards Act in the US) strictly regulate off-the-clock work. Under the law:

  1. If you are required to remain on site or follow employer directions, you must be paid.

  2. "Voluntary" work is not legal if it benefits the employer. Even if a boss says an event is optional, if employees are pressured, expected to attend, or doing work that benefits the business (like marketing), it is legally work time.

  3. Short mid-shift breaks must be paid. A single unpaid 60-minute gap sandwiched right in the middle of your workday (between 2 PM and 3 PM) is usually considered a "short rest period" or "waiting time" (being "engaged to wait"), which must be compensated unless you are completely relieved of all duties and free to leave the premises to pursue your own personal business without penalty.

Key Dilemmas & Practical Realities

  • Peer Pressure Creates a Trap: When 75% of your coworkers go along with unpaid hours, it normalizes wage theft and makes setting boundaries feel like dynamic suicide.

  • Retaliation Risk: While your boss cannot legally fire you for refusing to work unpaid, "at-will" employment environments mean bad bosses often retaliate covertly (e.g., cutting your scheduled hourly shifts, giving bad assignments, or suddenly writing you up for minor things).

Step-by-Step Options to Handle This

Option 1: The "Paper Trail" Clarification (Low-to-Medium Risk)

Instead of throwing a refusal in your boss's face during a meeting, ask for clarification via email or text. This forces them to put illegal demands in writing (which they rarely will do) or back down.

"Hi [Boss Name], I wanted to confirm how hours are being tracked for the ad interview from 2:00 PM to 3:00 PM today. Since my shift runs from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, should I clock out at 2:00 PM and leave the premises, or stay on the clock while helping with the event?"

Why this works: It politely frames the situation in black-and-white operational terms. Bosses who know they are bending rules often back off when they realize an employee is creating a written paper trail.

Option 2: Take the Full Unpaid Hour Away from Work

If you decide not to participate, do not stay in the building or hang around the breakroom.

  • Clock out at 2:00 PM.

  • Physically leave the building (go get coffee, sit in your car, run an errand).

  • Return and clock back in precisely at 3:00 PM.

Why this works: It establishes that if time is truly unpaid, your time is 100% yours. If your boss complains that you left the building during an unpaid period, they are proving that attendance was actually mandatory (which makes it illegal not to pay you).

Option 3: Document Everything & File a Wage Claim

If you decide to go along with it to protect your job for now, or if you end up walking away later:

  1. Keep a private log: Write down every date, time, and specific event where you or your coworkers were asked to work unpaid, along with copies of schedule texts, emails, or shift logs.

  2. File a report: You can submit a confidential complaint to your local or state/national labor board (Department of Labor). Labor boards take wage theft very seriously and can audit the employer, forcing them to back-pay you and your coworkers for all past unpaid hours.

Moving Forward

Start looking for another job in the background. A company that relies on skimming hours off hourly workers to cut costs is showing deep financial stress or bad managerial ethics. That culture rarely gets better over time.

Found a new job… current employer offered a promotion the same day. Which should I take?

Really odd situation I find myself in. I decided to leave my company after a 7 year tenure because there’s no growth and wages became stagnant. I have found a new job and planned on turning in my two weeks.

Today, before I could even discuss the transition with anyone, I am approached by a different department head and asked to interview internally for a promotion. No way this is a coincidence, right? But how could they possibly know?

I have already committed to this new job with higher pay and gave them a definitive start date, and signed an offer letter. But now my company has me second guessing myself. Going to take the weekend to make a decision and either give my two weeks or not starting Monday.

Hoping to hear from other people’s experiences. I’m almost wondering if I should level with my boss and tell him I was planning on leaving, but offer to interview internally anyway. But I’m wondering if that will just make them say to forget it.

What would you do?


Jobadvisor

First off, congratulations. Getting a new job offer and an internal promotion opportunity on the exact same day is a high-class problem to have, even if it feels dizzying right now.

To answer your first question: Yes, it is almost certainly a coincidence (or office gossip/grapevine movement). Unless your new employer reached out to your current company for a reference check that leaked, departments in mid-to-large companies rarely coordinate like that. Your timing was just uncanny.

Here is a breakdown of how to think through this over the weekend, along with a reality check on why counter-offers are notoriously tricky.

The Reality Check: Why Counter-Offers Rarely Work Long-Term

Data and career coaching wisdom overwhelmingly suggest that accepting a counter-offer from your current employer is a gamble. Statistically, a large percentage of people who accept a counter-offer leave—or are pushed out—within 12 to 18 months anyway.

Here is why:

  • The root cause hasn't changed: You spent 7 years feeling stuck with stagnant wages and zero growth. One department head offering you an interview doesn't fix the systemic culture or management style of the company that kept you flat for nearly a decade.

  • Trust is fractured: The moment you hint that you were leaving, you become a "flight risk" in leadership's eyes. Future promotions, high-visibility projects, or raises may be guarded because management now views your loyalty as conditional.

  • The "guilt" promotion: You might get the promotion, but it could come with resentment from peers who have been vying for it longer, or from leadership who feel they were forced into it.

Your Two Options Analyzed

Option A: Stick with the New Job (The Recommended Route)

You already interviewed, got selected, negotiated higher pay, signed an offer letter, and committed a start date. That new job represents the exact thing you were missing: growth, fresh perspective, and a market-rate salary.

  • Pros: A clean break, a guaranteed escape from 7 years of stagnation, and professional momentum. You validated your worth on the open market.

  • Cons: Leaving the comfort of the familiar and facing the startup friction of a new workplace.

Option B: Explore the Internal Promotion

If you genuinely love the company culture, your colleagues, and the company's mission—and your only issue was stagnation—you could entertain the conversation. However, do not use it to leverage a bidding war.

If you decide to talk to them, do not say, "Match this new offer or I'm walking." Instead, frame it around your career evolution: "I was actually looking at external opportunities because I felt my growth here had plateaued, but I'm open to discussing internal paths if the scope of this role is right."

  • The Catch: As you worried in your post, telling them you have one foot out the door might cause them to rescind the interview invitation immediately. Management hates being cornered.

What I Would Do

I would stick with the new job and decline the internal interview.

Here is why: Seven years is a long time at a single company, especially one where wages stagnated and growth stalled. It is very easy for familiarity and Stockholm Syndrome to kick in the moment current management dangles a shiny carrot. They had 7 years to notice your talent and promote you proactively; it took you getting an external foot out the door to get their attention.

Take the new job. It gives you a clean slate, an immediate pay bump, and a chance to prove yourself in an environment that values you from day one.


Automation Developer to AI Engineer?

Hi, I work as an automation developer( female, age: 30). My team mostly work with MS power platforms, Sharepoint, Azure services and RPA. Right now my pay is $123k. It’s been 4.5 years I am in the company. I started at $105k and then got promoted. I have a good reputation in the team. My manager and senior manager like me. I get things done and my work has always been appreciated. However, my work has recently become monotonous and I am thinking for a better pay and change. Honestly, I always wanted to work in ML fields. I did my Master’s thesis in ML but I was in a hurry to get a job because of visa restrictions. So I took this job thinking I would change it. Then, lot of things happened. Personal life issues and I never got a chance to think of changing job. Now that I am stable, now I feel like I am not using my full potential I am stuck in this field. I am not enjoying my work either. I want to work in AI engineering field. If you were me what would be your next step? I am really struggling to create a career path for me from where I am at right now…


Jobadvisor

First off, take a breath. You are in a remarkably strong position.

You hold a Master’s degree with a thesis in ML, you have 4.5 years of proven corporate execution, you earn a solid mid-six-figure salary ($123k), and you have strong soft skills and a reputation for getting things done. That is not a dead end—that is a rock-solid foundation.

The bridge from Automation Developer to AI Engineer is much shorter than you think, especially right now. The market doesn't just need ML researchers who build models from scratch; it critically needs AI Engineers who know how to connect LLMs, cloud architecture, APIs, and business workflows. Your background in Azure, Power Platform, APIs, and RPA is actually an incredible asset for modern AI application development.

Here is a 4-step strategic roadmap to transition your career without resetting your salary or starting from scratch.

Step 1: Shift Your Mindset (The "AI Engineer" Spectrum)

There are two main buckets in the AI world today:

  1. Machine Learning / Data Scientist: Focuses on training models, data math, feature engineering, and algorithms ($PyTorch$, $TensorFlow$, $scikit-learn$).

  2. AI Engineer (Software / Solutions): Focuses on leveraging existing AI models (OpenAI API, Anthropic, open-source models via Hugging Face), orchestration frameworks (LangChain, LlamaIndex), enterprise vector databases, RAG systems, and integrating them into enterprise applications via Cloud/APIs.

Given your background in Azure, automation, and cloud services—plus your ML thesis foundation—your fastest, highest-paying path is AI Engineer / Enterprise AI Solutions Engineer.

Step 2: Leverage Your Current Role (The "Internal Pivot")

Since your manager and senior manager already like you and trust your delivery, do not quit or job hunt externally just yet. Use your current workplace as a safe playground to build AI experience on their dime.

  • Introduce AI to your current workflows: Start integrating Azure OpenAI Service, AI Builder, or custom API calls to LLMs into your existing Power Platform, SharePoint, and RPA automation pipelines.

  • Build a "RAG" (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) prototype: Propose a small internal tool (e.g., an automated Assistant that queries internal company documents in SharePoint/Azure using OpenAI + Vector Search).

  • Update your title/responsibilities internally: Pitch this to your manager: "I’d love to take on more AI integration initiatives to automate complex unstructured tasks." This lets you put "AI Engineering / Intelligent Automation" on your resume while keeping your $123k safety net.

Step 3: Fill the Technical Gaps (Your Weekend / Evening Upskilling)

Because you already have an ML thesis, you don't need to re-learn basic linear algebra or statistics. You just need modern AI developer tooling.

Focus strictly on these tech stacks over the next 3–4 months:

AreaFocus Tools & Frameworks
Primary LanguagePython (Move away from low-code/GUI tools to full Python scripting)
LLM OrchestrationLangChain or LlamaIndex
APIs & BackendFastAPI, REST APIs, Docker basics
Vector DatabasesPinecone, ChromaDB, or Azure AI Search
Cloud AI PlatformAzure OpenAI Service, Azure Machine Learning Studio (Leverage your existing Azure familiarity)

Step 4: Craft Your Transition Resume & Market Positioning

When you apply for external AI Engineer roles (targeting $140k–$175k+), frame your 4.5 years of experience through an AI lens:

  • Old framing: "Built RPA bots and Power Automate flows for business processes."

  • New framing: "Engineered enterprise-grade automated workflows, integrating REST APIs, cloud microservices, and AI-driven document processing pipelines."

Companies love AI Engineers who actually understand enterprise deployment, security, cloud infrastructure, and business process automation. Pure ML graduates often lack the business delivery experience you already possess.


How do I move to my next steps after staying too long at my current job?

I’m in my mid 20s and I’m at a job in the non profit sector for about the past 3 years. I absolutely adore my coworkers and the core mission of the work we do is down my alley. The downside is that I have been slowly coming to the conclusion that I’ve let myself be taken advantage of completely. I have been the lead on three huge projects for work (and executed them very well) just in the past year. I have quality and integrity in my work that all my coworkers regularly vouch for me. And personally, I used to do a 2 hour commute and eventually moved for this job, I gave up grad school twice for this job because I was promised exposure to research. All of this, and I recently found out (during the peak of an insane campaign they completely had me working insane hours and effort on) that I get paid the actual LEAST out of all full time workers across all programs. Like everyone else has been up for a raise before me. I feel so hurt and so like “holy crap I should’ve left sooner” but I just kept sticking out hoping that my hard work would be recognized. If anything good, my coworkers are equally as depressed that I never got a raise when they did. There’s more too, but for the sake of already being an essay into this, y’all get the point.

Like the title says, I know I want to leave, I’m just struggling finding out what order of next steps would make most sense. I want to go back to school but I also feel like I can’t leave this job without a letter of recommendation, which I can’t do if I burn bridges with my bosses. I feel like I am in a catch 22 and either move feels like existentially impossible.


Jobadvisor

You're in a hard spot, and it makes sense that the discovery about your pay stung. Three years of carrying major projects in good faith, only to learn you were paid the least, would hurt anyone. Staying was a reasonable choice based on trust that your work would be seen. The fact that you feel this now doesn't mean you were foolish.

I also think the catch-22 is less absolute than it feels. A letter of recommendation doesn't require staying on good terms with everyone, and it doesn't require your current boss at all. Here's an order that might help:

  1. Document what you've done. Write down the three big projects: your role, the outcomes, the numbers, and any praise in emails or messages. Ask coworkers who've seen your work whether they'd be willing to speak to it. This protects you whatever you decide, and it gives you material for a raise conversation, a resume, and a grad school application.

  2. Check your market rate. Look at salary data for your role in comparable nonprofits and in your target field (Candid, Idealist, and nonprofit salary surveys are good places to start). Knowing the real number makes any conversation about pay concrete instead of emotional.

  3. Decide whether to ask for a raise. Asking doesn't have to be a threat or an ultimatum. You can say you've reviewed your contributions and the market, and you'd like to discuss your compensation. Their response will tell you a lot. If they stall or dismiss you, you'll have a clear answer and a paper trail. If they engage, you may get a better deal while you plan. Either way, you're not burning a bridge by asking a fair question.

  4. Line up recommenders now. You don't need your boss. A former professor from your earlier grad school attempts, a mentor in the field, or a senior colleague who watched you lead a project can all write strong letters. Ask them early, while you still have time.

  5. Look at grad school timing and funding. Many programs have application deadlines in the fall or winter, so you may be able to apply while still employed and start on your own schedule. Look specifically for funded programs with research assistantships, since that's the exposure you were promised and never got.

  6. Build a financial runway. Even a rough estimate of how many months you could cover without income will make the leap feel less impossible, and it will shape whether you leave before or after school.

If you're open to it, tell me roughly where you are on the money side and which grad programs or fields you're considering. I can help you think through timing from there.


How do you explain a career change when you don’t have direct experience?

People changing careers often introduce themselves by apologising for everything they have not done yet. They say they lack direct experience, are trying to break into a new industry and know their background is unusual. This immediately puts attention on the gap. A stronger approach is to explain what connects the old career to the new one. Maybe you understand customers because you worked directly with them. Maybe you are moving into operations because you were already fixing broken processes. Maybe you want to become a manager because the part of your previous job you enjoyed most was developing other people. The change should feel like a logical next step rather than a random restart. Your introduction needs a clear thread. What have you consistently been good at? What made you want to do more of it? Why does the new direction make sense now? If you are trying to change careers, share your current role and target role. I’ll help you find the connection between them.


Jobadvisor

This framing is useful, and the thread you describe is usually what hiring managers are listening for. You can build it from three questions:

  1. What have you consistently done well? Look for the pattern across roles, not just the job title. "Managed budgets" and "kept projects on schedule" might both be "I make complicated things run."
  2. What did you enjoy about doing it? The enjoyable part usually points toward the target role.
  3. Why does the new direction make sense now? This is the part that shows you chose the move deliberately, rather than drifting into it.

A version of the intro might sound like: "I've spent four years in customer support, where I kept noticing that the same complaints came from the same broken processes. Lately I've been drawn to fixing those processes at the source, which is why I'm moving into operations." That names the current role, the skill, the pull toward the new work, and the reason for the change, without apologizing for the gap.

Share your current role and your target role, and I'll help you find the connection between them. If you can, include a couple of specific things you did or enjoyed in your current job, since those details usually make the thread clearest.


What to do if your salary negotiation fails?

Hi all, I’m feeling a bit discouraged and am now seeking some advice.

I’m a new-grad, having recently graduated with a master’s in Computer Science in May after taking a 1-year gap from obtaining my undergraduate degree. For 4.5 years now, I’ve worked as a medical scribe for a rather large hospital system in my state and have been applying for jobs relating to healthcare data analytics for the past 1-2 years, but have been having pretty sour luck navigating the job market. I have 100+ applications in the system, likely more, but have had only a handful interviews—all resulting in me being ghosted.

I figured it was likely due to my lack of technical experience (as I didn’t decide on this path until the end of my undergrad and therefore do not have any internships), but I realized I should try to leverage the experience I do have, which is at my hospital system as an EPIC user. Pretty quickly, I finally got a bit of luck and secured an internal opportunity to move into our Revenue Cyclic Management team. However, it was simultaneously undergoing a title/salary change, having previously been a pretty low hourly rate ($24/hr), but is now salaried with with an approximate range of $52k-73k. Of course, the jobs that I’ve been applying to were at a higher rate than this, but this is a bit outside of the realm of data analytics yet I figured it would be an excellent stepping stone for me.

While I don’t have a lot of technical experience outside of academics, I figured I could definitely leverage what I DO have, which is my scribing experience and master’s degree, to try and negotiate closer to $65k in hopes of meeting midway. I got my offer letter today of $52k, the starting range, and while I initially planned to email my negotiation I decided to instead call (partly due to impatience, admittedly, but also in hopes that doing it real-time would get me a bit farther). However, I didn’t even get a chance to throw an offer out there because I was told that the Employee Compensation team had a note on my file that my rate was decided based upon it being a substantial increase from my scribing role. I insisted anyway, so she said she’d send Comp an email to “reconfirm” my rate and I’ll hear back by Monday.

I’m now just feeling a bit discouraged as I feel like I didn’t even get to give a target range or really explain my case. I started my current position as a senior in college, and lots of us in my scribing team are students who started the job either during or in-between schooling, so I feel like it’s unfair to base my new salary off of that rate, which is barely over minimum wage. There’s a high turnover rate in my job, but that’s expected. I just feel like HR/Employee Comp wouldn’t know that much, and I feel like I should’ve tried mentioning that during the call.

Now, I’m weighing my options. Should I send the recruiter an email with further information pleading my case, or refrain from doing so as to not seem too pushy? Or is there hope of me potentially asking for a re-evaluation on my salary 6-12 months in? I don’t think I’ll particularly lose the offer, as the hiring manager really likes me, but I’ve never negotiated before and I’m not sure what to do. Any advice is appreciated!


Jobadvisor

First off, deep breath: you have not ruined your offer, and you are in a far better position than you feel right now.

Getting stuck on the bottom of a salary band because of "internal transfer caps" or past hourly pay is an infuriatingly common corporate practice—especially in large healthcare systems. Compensation departments routinely use rules like "promotions/transfers cannot exceed a X% increase over previous pay" to save money, regardless of how irrelevant your old student/scribe wage is to your new professional role.

Here is a clear breakdown of what is happening behind the scenes, how to handle the immediate next steps, and your broader strategy.

1. The Immediate Dilemma: Should You Email the Recruiter Now?

No, do not send a long email pleading your case before Monday.

Since the recruiter already agreed to reach back out to the Employee Compensation team, sending a follow-up email right now will likely come across as anxious or over-eager.

Wait for their call/email on Monday. When they contact you, here is how to handle the two likely outcomes:

Scenario A: They say the $52k is firm

Do not get emotional or try to debate your past scribe wage on the spot. State your value cleanly:

"Thank you for checking with Compensation. Given my Master’s in Computer Science and 4.5 years of deep familiarity with our EPIC systems, I was really hoping we could find a middle ground closer to $60k–$65k to reflect the technical scope of the role. If $52k is truly the firm cap for day one, can we put a formal 6-month performance and salary review into the offer letter?"

Scenario B: They budge slightly (e.g., offer $55k–$57k)

Take the win, express gratitude, and accept the offer.

2. A Reality Check on Your Current Position

It is completely valid to feel underpaid at $52k when holding a Master’s in CS. However, let's look at your macro position:

FactorWhere You WereWhat This Job Gives You
Title / RoleHourly Scribe (Near min-wage)Salaried Revenue Cycle / Healthcare Data
Market Traction100+ applications, 0 offers, ghosted1 real internal stepping stone
Resume ValueAcademic projects onlyReal-world EPIC / Enterprise Data experience
Right now, the tech and analytics job market for new grads without internships is brutally competitive. Your biggest bottleneck wasn't your salary expectation—it was the lack of non-academic technical experience on your resume.

This job breaks that wall down. The moment you hold this role for 6 to 12 months, your resume transforms from "CS grad who worked as a scribe" to "Healthcare Data / Revenue Analyst with a CS Master's and hands-on EPIC experience."

3. Your Action Plan (The 12-Month Playbook)

If the salary stays at $52k, accept the job anyway, but change your mindset: treat this role as a paid, full-time fellowship to launch your healthcare analytics career.

[Month 0-6: Lock In] ➔ [Month 6: Internal Review Request] ➔ [Month 9-12: External Market Search]
  1. Months 1–6 (Build your portfolio): Learn the data structures behind Revenue Cycle Management. Get your hands on SQL, EPIC reporting tools (Cogito, Radar, Hyperspace data, Clarity/Caboodle if accessible), and Tableau/Power BI.

  2. Month 6 (The Internal Ask): Go to your hiring manager (who already likes you). Frame it around impact: "I’ve automated X reports and streamlined Y revenue workflows over the past 6 months. Can we re-evaluate my compensation band toward the team average?"

  3. Months 9–12 (The External Leap): If your current employer won't bump your pay significantly, start applying externally. With 1 year of actual enterprise healthcare data experience + a CS Master's + EPIC knowledge, you will easily qualify for Data Analyst / Healthcare Analytics roles in the $75,000 – $95,000+ range.

What I Would Do

Take a step back and look at the trajectory: you are jumping from an hourly scribe position into your first professional corporate role inside a major healthcare system.

If they give you a higher starting number on Monday, fantastic. If they hold firm at $52k, take the job, swallow the temporary sting, and use them for the experience just like they are using the policy to save a few thousand dollars. In 12 months, you'll hold all the cards.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post