Most of us think we’re pretty good at spotting a liar. We watch the eyes. We study the smile. We wait for that nervous glance away. According to psychologist Leanne ten Brinke, almost all of that is wrong.
On a recent episode of The Diary of a CEO, ten Brinke—author of Poisonous People—walked through what decades of research actually show about deception and the “dark tetrad” of personality traits: narcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathy, and sadism. These traits sit on a spectrum. People who score high on them tend to be charming, impulsive, remorseless, and skilled at manipulation. And they lie a lot—sometimes to get what they want, sometimes just to put someone else down.
The uncomfortable truth? The average person detects lies only about 54 percent of the time. That’s barely better than a coin flip.
The Myths We Still Believe
Ask almost anyone how they spot a liar and the answer comes quickly: sketchy eye contact. Ten Brinke says there is simply no solid research supporting that idea. Gaze aversion is one of the most widely believed cues and one of the least reliable.
The same goes for smiles. Many people have heard of the Duchenne smile—the genuine one that creates crow’s feet around the eyes—versus the polite smile that only moves the mouth. A smile that doesn’t reach the eyes can feel fake, but it doesn’t automatically signal deception. People smile for social reasons, politeness, or habit all the time. It’s a weak signal at best.
What Actually Gives Liars Away
Liars are not impossible to detect. The more consistent signs involve cognitive effort. When someone is inventing a story on the spot, the mental load shows up in small ways: more “ums,” “uhs,” and “ers.” They may furrow their brow, pause longer, or seem to be searching for the next piece of the story. None of these is a perfect tell, but they are reliably linked to deception.
The single strongest difference between truth-tellers and liars is the amount of detail they provide. Truthful accounts tend to be richer and more specific. Fabrications often stay vague or lean heavily on tangential information that is easier to invent and harder to check.
A Better Way to Catch a Lie
Closed questions that invite a simple yes or no make it easy for someone to stay in the story. Open questions that push for more detail force the liar to keep building. The more they have to invent, the more gaps appear.
One practical test Ten Brinke recommends is simply asking how verifiable a statement is. When people stick to the parts of a story that are hard to check and avoid the parts that could be confirmed, that pattern itself becomes useful information.
Eye contact and forced smiles make for dramatic television. In real life they mostly mislead us. The research points somewhere quieter and more practical: watch for mental effort, demand detail, and pay attention to what can actually be verified. Those habits won’t turn you into a human lie detector, but they will move you well above that 54 percent baseline.
