Be brutally honest. Am I just not cut out for engineering ?

 


Be brutally honest. Am I just not cut out for engineering (LONG)?


i'm 19 and a freshman

my memory has always been pretty shit, even since i was a kid, and it got even worse because of my depression and isolation between the ages of 12 and 15

even before my depression when i was young i struggled so much with memory (but always loved math). once physics and chemistry started getting harder i could barely keep up with studying them. i had to completely isolate myself from my family and friends just to pass and get into engineering

i've always taken much longer than most people to understand things that others might find simple, at least academically

when i finally got into a great engineering university, i was so happy. i made friends and i was excited to start. i never stopped studying. i used to take tons of notes when i was 16 (to 18) because that was the only way i could manage to pass. i couldn't focus properly no matter how hard i tried unless i typed things out but that wasted so much of my time. eventually i stopped taking notes altogether because i knew i'd be digging my own grave by spending so much time on them, especially as someone who's already a slow learner in such a stressful major

i even tried using ai to make notes for me, but i realized that was wasting time too so i stopped doing that completely in week 3

now i'm in week 7, and my midterms are next week. i'm nowhere near ready

i haven't wasted a single day since the semester started because i knew i was slower than most people. i was always careful with my time, tried to understand everything, pushed myself as much as i could, and even tried to watch online lectures before attending the actual ones. but i still can't keep up. i barely have enough time to study the previous lectures before new ones pile up, and now i'm behind by around four lectures in physics / math and statics

engineering drawing is another example of how much i struggle with speed. whenever i try to push myself to work faster and finish the classwork during the section, i just can't do it. no matter how much i practice, i'm still too slow to finish on time. it's especially frustrating because drawing is probably the course i've put the most effort into, simply because i don't want to look stupid

whenever i study anything, i try to work quickly and set timers for myself. but i take so long to understand things that the timer goes off before i've even finished half of what i planned to do. then i start panicking because how the fuck has an entire hour already passed, and i haven't even gotten halfway through?

even when i have a quiz, i'll tell myself that i'll study for it and then briefly cover a lecture from another course. somehow, i can't even finish preparing for the quiz itself

i try so hard to stay disciplined and not let it get to me, but fuck it's exhausting when my brain feels like mush from all the effort i'm putting in, while the results aren't even close to what i hoped for

even when i feel down, i still get up and try to do better. but i'm starting to think i'll fail my midterms because of how long it takes me to understand lectures and solve even a reasonable number of practice problems

i genuinely don't know what i'm supposed to do anymore. i'm trying as hard as i can, but it feels like my best is still not enough

engineering isn't really my passion, but i have the patience to study it because i believe discipline is one of the most important things

but now i'm so anxious. I keep thinking about how i'll eventually have to compete for jobs with people who are much smarter and more talented than me and it makes me wonder if i'm really willing to struggle this much for the rest of my life


Jobadvisor

You asked for brutal honesty, so here it is: the evidence you've given me doesn't show that you're not cut out for engineering. It shows that the way you're working isn't working, and you've been trying to fix it by pushing harder, which is why you're exhausted.

Some of what you described is worth looking at directly. You have a long history of memory trouble, trouble focusing unless you're typing, and taking much longer than others to process material, and it has all been alongside depression and isolation. That pattern is worth a professional evaluation for things like ADHD, a learning difference, or anxiety and depression that have been driving the problems. It doesn't mean something is wrong with you, and I can't diagnose you from a Reddit post. But you've been treating this as a discipline problem for years, and it may be a medical or cognitive one that nobody has checked.

Some of your strategies are also working against you. Trying to fully understand every lecture before moving on, watching lectures in advance while still behind on the previous ones, and setting an hour timer that you can't finish within are a recipe for falling further behind. Quitting notes in week 3 was probably a mistake. Your brain clearly needs to get the material out of your head and onto a page to hold onto it, so the typing was a clue, not a waste. Engineering in the first years rewards doing lots of problems and getting them wrong quickly far more than understanding everything perfectly the first time. Speed in drawing comes mostly from repetition and technique, not from natural talent, and it can improve a lot with the right practice.

For the next week, I'd focus on three things. First, email your professor or TA today and tell them you're four lectures behind and worried about the midterm. Ask which topics matter most and whether there are practice exams. Second, go to your university's disability services and counseling center this week. Tell them what you told me, including the memory problems and the history of depression. They can assess you and may offer accommodations like extra time on exams, which matter a lot for someone who processes slowly. Third, look up your university's course withdrawal deadline. Failing a midterm is not failing the course, and knowing your options will make the next week less frightening.

About the job worry: you're comparing your week 7 to other people's finished careers. Plenty of engineers were slow learners in school, and what determines whether someone succeeds is persistence, good fundamentals, and getting help when they need it. Right now you're trying to do all of that alone, which is the real problem.

One more question, because it matters more than the grades: how are you doing day to day? Are you sleeping, eating, and seeing people? You mentioned that the isolation you went through before got worse with depression. If any of that is creeping back, that's worth telling someone at your school's counseling center now, not after the midterms.


Talking about pay at work backfired on me, how do I handle it?

Hello everyone,

I'm in a situation I didn't expect and I'm not sure how to handle it.

A few days ago, a coworker and I were talking about salary raises and the cost of living and I didn't really see a reason to hide it, so I told them. They shared their salary too, and we realized there's a pretty big difference even though we do almost the same job.

I didn't think much of it at the time. I wasn't trying to cause problems or encourage anyone to complain so I just answered honestly.
Well, word got around the office.

now my manager called me into their office and said
HR wants to meet with me. They didn't say anything but they did mention that talking about pay can
"cause problems" in the workplace.
Now I'm stressed because I honestly wasn't trying to start drama or get anyone upset. It was just a conversation between coworkers.
I've read that employees can discuss their salaries, but I don't know if that's true everywhere or how I should handle the meeting with HR.

Has anyone else been in a similar situation? How did you handle the HR conversation, and is there anything I should or shouldn't say during the meeting?

Thanks in advance


Jobadvisor

The short answer is that you probably haven't done anything wrong, but the law on this is less settled than you might hope, especially if you're in Romania.

On the legal question: the EU Pay Transparency Directive (2023/970) is designed to make it easier for employees to find out whether they're being paid unfairly, and it protects employees who discuss pay for that purpose. Romania had to put it into national law by 7 June 2026. As of the most recent sources I could find, the Romanian draft was still going through parliament, and I couldn't confirm that it's in force. So "employees can discuss their salaries" is the direction of the law, but I can't tell you the exact rule that applies to your workplace today. An employment contract might also contain a confidentiality clause, which is worth checking, although a clause like that may not be enforceable against a discussion about pay. Before you rely on any of this, call the Labour Inspectorate (ITM) or ask a union or employment lawyer. Many offer a free first consultation.

For the HR meeting, a few things will help:

  • Stay calm and factual. Don't apologize for having the conversation, but don't argue that the company is wrong either until you know what they're actually worried about.
  • Ask them to be specific. Find out whether they're citing a written policy, whether this is a formal complaint, and whether anyone has been disciplined. If they mention consequences, ask them to confirm in writing.
  • Don't name your coworker's salary or speculate about who said what. You can say you discussed pay with a colleague and that you didn't set out to cause problems. Protecting your coworker also protects you.
  • Don't sign anything in the meeting. You can say you'd like time to review, or take a copy home.
  • Take notes right after the meeting, while you still remember the wording, and save any messages from your manager or HR.

Think about what you actually want from this. If the pay gap between you and your coworker is real, the conversation could become a request for a pay review based on your role and experience. You're allowed to ask your employer how your pay is set and whether it's fair. If you go in with that question, the meeting is more likely to end somewhere useful than if it's only about defending yourself.

Finally, if you feel pressured to stay quiet, or if things get worse after this meeting, such as being excluded, given worse shifts, or threatened, write down the dates and details and get legal advice quickly. Retaliation for raising or discussing pay is the thing these rules exist to prevent.


Applying for job with a salary range of $82,000 to $110,000. What should I put down for my desired salary?

Hello! I am applying for a job that I really want and I am wondering what to put for my desired salary. It is a role in municipal government and I recently graduated with my Master's in Public Policy. The minimum qualifications for this role are a Bachelor's degree + 3 years of experience with experience in housing, public engagement, and leadership.

My qualifications are as follows:
- I have a Master's degree in public policy with a focus on housing and community development. During graduate school (2 years) I worked at a non-profit that focused on climate action where I did two major research projects working with community leaders in a mid-level metropolitan area. I also worked at a transportation firm at an internship I did. After I got my Bachelor's degree, I worked at a non-profit that did housing grant development/management.

I am unsure of where to shoot for a salary because I feel underqualified for this role. I don't know if it is my disillusionment with the job market or if I am truly unqualified. I was thinking of saying that my desired salary was $85,000 as I am technically a new graduate. However, is it too low? Is it too high? What should my number be?

Thanks in advance,

A confused job applicant


Jobadvisor

First off, let’s clear up the imposter syndrome: you are not underqualified.

In municipal government and public sector hiring, a Master’s degree in Public Policy (MPP) typically substitutes for 1 to 2 years of required professional experience. Combined with your pre-grad non-profit work in housing grant development, your grad school research, and your transportation internship, you meet—if not exceed—the candidate profile for an entry-to-mid-level municipal role.

Target $92,000 to $95,000 on your application (or state $92,000 if forced to enter a single number).

Here is why $85,000 is too low, along with how to approach the salary prompt strategically.

Why $85,000 is Undervalued

  1. The MPP Premium: You hold a specialized Master’s degree directly aligned with the job’s core focus (housing and community development). Municipalities value relevant Master's degrees because they require minimal training in policy analysis and memo writing.

  2. Direct Domain Experience: You aren't coming in cold. You have actual hands-on experience in housing grant management, public engagement with community leaders, and interdisciplinary policy work.

  3. Public Sector Compensation Structure: Municipal salary bands are tied to strict pay grades and steps. Anchor yourself in the lower-middle portion of the band ($90k–$95k) rather than near the floor ($82k). Entering near the floor leaves almost no room to negotiate during the offer stage, and starting at the bottom makes it harder to catch up via annual step raises.

How to Answer the Salary Question

Depending on the format of the job application, use one of these three approaches:

Application FormatRecommended AnswerStrategy
Open Text Box"Negotiable / Open to discussing based on the total compensation package"Avoids locking you into a number before learning about benefits, pension contributions, and healthcare.
Salary Range Box$90,000 – $98,000Shows you value your Master's degree while keeping you well within their approved budget band.
Single Number Required$92,000Positioned comfortably in the lower-middle of their $82k–$110k range—fair for an advanced degree holder with early-career experience.

Key Takeaways for Your Mindset

  • Municipalities have set budgets: Pitching $92,000 will not price you out of consideration because it sits comfortably within their published range.

  • Anchor high enough to negotiate: If you ask for $85,000, they may offer you $82,000 (the minimum). If you ask for $92,000, it gives both sides room to settle around $88,000–$90,000.

  • Highlight substitution in your cover letter: Frame your degree and grant experience directly against their requirements (e.g., "Combining my Master’s degree in Public Policy focused on housing with direct experience in grant development...").


How do you recover from a boss who secretly ruined your reputation by trying to "protect" you?

I have been a backend engineer at a fintech company for nearly two years. My manager has always been extremely polite. In fact, he never pushed back on my pull requests. While other engineers on the team got roasted in review comments, mine were always approved with a friendly "Looks solid!" within ten minutes.

I genuinely thought I was performing at the top of the team.

then promotion cycles rolled around last week. A junior guy who started six months after me got bumped to senior. I was completely blindsided.

I went to a coffee shop with our lead architect to ask what skills I lacked. He looked at his cup, sighed, and told me the truth. My manager has been quietly rewriting my database queries and fixing edge cases on his own branch before pushing my code to production. Apparently my manager told the team he didn't want to "discourage" me with harsh feedback because tech is tough on women.

It was the most HUMILIATING moment of my professional life. While everyone else got real mentoring, I was treated like a fragile child who couldn't handle red ink. The entire engineering department secretly thinks I am incompetent because they see his cleanup commits on GitHub.

I probably should of checked the production commit logs earlier, but I trusted my direct supervisor.

Now I am sitting in my car during my lunch break staring at job boards, realizing my two years of experience here are completely worthless.


Jobadvisor

What happened to you was a real betrayal of your trust, and the humiliation makes sense. Your manager made a decision about your career without telling you, and the reason he gave, that tech is tough on women so he didn't want to discourage you, was a gendered assumption about what you could handle. You didn't get the feedback you needed for two years, and you were told you were doing well when you weren't getting the same review as everyone else. That's a serious failure on his part, and it's not something you caused by trusting him.

I also want to push back on one thing: your two years aren't worthless. You've spent that time building a system you know and shipping code to production in a fintech environment, which is hard. What's missing is an accurate picture of your skills, and you can get that. The gaps your architect hinted at, probably in query performance and handling edge cases, are specific and learnable, and specific gaps are much easier to close than a vague sense of being "not senior enough."

Before you decide anything, go back to the architect and ask him for specifics. Ask which queries needed rewriting, what the edge cases were, and what a senior engineer would have done differently in each case. Ask him to look at your next few PRs and tell you directly what he'd change. Having a senior person who will be honest with you is worth more right now than almost anything else.

Next, document everything while it's fresh. Save the PRs, the dates of the approvals, the cleanup commits, the promotion timeline, and what the architect told you, including what you said and what he said. Write down your own recollection of the coffee-shop conversation today, in your own words. This matters for two reasons: it gives you a record if you decide to raise this formally, and it helps you think clearly rather than from the car.

About the promotion decision and the reason your manager gave: you have a legitimate basis to raise it with HR or a skip-level manager, because a decision that rests on an assumption about women's ability to handle criticism is the kind of thing HR is supposed to look at. You don't have to go in angry or accuse him of anything you can't prove. You can say you learned that your code was being changed before it reached production, that you weren't given the same feedback as your peers, and that you want to understand the promotion decision and the reasoning behind it. Whether you want to pursue this further, and how hard, is your call. But you don't have to choose between fixing this and leaving. You can do both.

On your colleagues: you can't fully control what they think now, but you can change the evidence over the next few months. Pick up a hard piece of work, own it end to end, and make sure your code goes through review like everyone else's, with real comments. Over time the commit history will show what you can do without help.

As for the job boards, it's completely reasonable to look, and I'd suggest you do. Looking doesn't mean you've given up on this team. It gives you options and a sense of your market value, which may be higher than you feel right now. Try not to make a big decision from the car on your lunch break. Give yourself a few days to talk to the architect and decide what you want.

How are you feeling about the team right now: do you want to stay and rebuild your reputation here, or does the idea of working with your manager again make you want to leave? Your answer changes what I'd suggest next.


AI will inevitably replace a lot of white collar office jobs in 5-10 years if not sooner… what should I do?

My mind is spinning with the constant news about layoffs, buyouts, and companies investing more in computing and AI data centers versus human labor. I don’t think I’m overreaching by saying that I don’t feel anyone in corporate America is safe, so curious what others are thinking/planning if this worst case scenario becomes a reality? I’m in my mid-30s and have a young child. I’ve worked in NYC corporate media for 10 years and I have a degree in communications. Right now I have some money via equity and 401-k (nothing crazy, under $100k) that I could use to pivot my career, but I really don’t know what is the right move. Is it buying a secure business from a boomer? Is it going back to school (even some sort of trade school?) is it investing? I’m hoping others in this sub have gone through a similar decision process and can share success stories of what they currently do and why they feel it’s a good long term bet.


Jobadvisor

The fear is reasonable, but "inevitably replace" is stronger than the evidence supports. So far AI is changing the tasks inside many jobs faster than it's eliminating whole roles, and many layoffs are about budgets, overhiring corrections, and shifting spending toward infrastructure rather than proof that a specific job is obsolete. Communications work is exposed in some ways, since first drafts, routine content, and basic production are increasingly automated. Work that depends on relationships, judgment, owning outcomes, and knowing a particular industry or audience holds up better. Nobody can reliably predict the timeline, so I'd plan for a range of outcomes rather than a single worst case.

That's also why I'd be cautious about making a large, irreversible move with your savings. You have a child, a mortgage or rent to consider, and perhaps $100k that is your main financial cushion. Before choosing a pivot, I'd first figure out how many months of expenses you could cover if you lost your job, and protect that amount. Leave your 401(k) alone if you can, since early withdrawals usually cost a penalty and taxes.

Among your options, buying a business can work well if you have operating, sales, or management experience and the business has steady, recurring revenue and a reason to exist that doesn't depend on one owner. Boomer-owned businesses can be good deals, but "secure" is something you have to verify through due diligence, not assume. Financing usually means an SBA loan on top of your savings, which adds debt to a family budget. Trade school is worth considering seriously. Electricians, HVAC, plumbing, and similar fields are hard to automate and in demand, but apprenticeships often pay better than school because you earn while you learn. Physical work also takes a toll, and it's a big identity shift, so talk to people in the trade before committing. Investing the money is fine for a portion of it, but treat it as a complement to income rather than a replacement for a plan.

The lowest-risk path is often to stay employed while you test options. Use your current role to build skills that pair your communications background with something harder to automate, like client management, data analysis, events, or a specific industry's expertise. Talk to people who work in the fields you're considering, shadow them if possible, and try small experiments: a short certification, a side project, or a small consulting client. That gives you real information about what you'd enjoy and what the work actually involves, before you spend your savings on the answer.

What part of your corporate media work do you find most valuable, such as the writing, the strategy, the people management, or the business side? That would help narrow down which directions are most realistic for you.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post