Did You Know Return-to-Office Playbooks Are Really Just Attrition Plans With Better Formatting?

 



Did you know that in 2024, 38% of employees had already been through multiple return-to-office mandates, and 6% had survived more than five? The authors of a recent Fast Company piece present that number as a symptom of bad policy design. I think it's a symptom of something else: companies that keep raising the requirement until the people they can't afford to lose leave.

Consider the retail firm in the article. It mandated three days, got two, then mandated four. The result was an average of three days a week and a wave of departures among "rule-followers," the employees who did what they were told. The authors file this under "botched reboots." I'd file it under "the policy working exactly as the company intended." Compliance went up. The people who actually cared about the work walked. Whether the company came out ahead is a question the article never asks.

The framing is the first problem. Attendance is treated as the goal, and employees are treated as inputs to hit it. Pillar 2 acknowledges that caregivers and deep-focus workers have real reasons to resist, then proposes a core-hours window so they can keep some flexibility. That's a concession dressed up as empathy. The advice is to shrink the mandate just enough that people stop complaining, not to ask whether the mandate was justified.

Pillar 3 is the most revealing. A five-day mandate timed for the day after Labor Day ran straight into the childcare gap that every working parent knows about. The authors call this a timing mistake. It was also a planning failure: the company didn't check whether its own policy worked for people with children. A policy that works only when the calendar cooperates was never designed for the workforce it claims to support.

Pillar 4 recommends that enforcement be "predictable" and that attendance be "transparent." The example is a system in which colleagues can see when someone last badge-in. That is surveillance, and calling it a team coordination tool doesn't change what it is. The recommended penalty is a small, steady bonus cut for each month of noncompliance. Bonuses are often a large share of total compensation for the people in the middle of the org chart, so "modest" depends on whose pay is being docked. The article also argues that early enforcement works because habits take two to five months to form. That's a rationale for applying pressure during the most disruptive window, when people are least able to adjust, and it's presented as a best practice.

Pillar 5 tells leaders to "respond to feedback" by adding shuttle buses and conference-room software. That's useful. But the feedback that matters most, such as "this policy doesn't fit my life" or "I'm not sure the work needs me here," gets no real hearing. The pillar assumes the policy is settled and that employees' job is to voice complaints about logistics.

Nowhere does the piece offer evidence that being in the office improves the work. It asserts that a fuller office "becomes more valuable" and creates a "pull," but the value is assumed, not shown. Given that the playbook depends on that assumption, it should be the first thing a leader checks, not the last.

So here's the uncomfortable question. If your return-to-office policy needs five pillars, stakeholder buy-in, escalating penalties, and a badge-swipe leaderboard to succeed, what it's really measuring might be how many people are willing to tolerate the mandate, not whether the mandate makes the company better.

If this made you uncomfortable, good. Tell me where I'm wrong in the comments.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post